Pizza On Fire

Pizza on Fire was an amazing experience—felt just like home! I tried the Meat Lover, and it’s definitely one to love. Packed with plenty of meat, not too saucy, and best of all, it’s halal. The service was impressive too. They promised it would be ready in 20 minutes, but I got my pizza in just 10. The staff was super friendly, and they offer delivery as well. Highly recommend this spot to anyone craving great pizza!

A Memorable First Visit to Pizza On Fire – Absolutely Worth It! We recently visited Pizza On Fire in Scarborough for the very first time, and I have to say—it was the perfect decision, especially for such a special occasion. We were celebrating my family member’s birthday on May 18th, and choosing this spot made the day even more unforgettable. We ordered the Tandoori Chicken Pizza, and it was absolutely delicious! The flavors were bold, rich, and perfectly balanced. The crust was baked just right—crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. You could really taste the care and quality in every bite. The tandoori chicken was juicy, well-seasoned, and added such a unique twist to the pizza. My family member was truly amazed, it was his favorite part of the meal! The atmosphere was cozy and welcoming, and the staff made us feel right at home. You can tell they put their heart into every pizza they make. We’re so glad we discovered Pizza On Fire, and it definitely won’t be our last visit. Thank you for making our celebration so special with your amazing food and service!

First found this place as a Doordash driver and thought since I was delivering to an elementary school not that close to the restaurant, it must be pretty good...cause that’s a lot of effort and cost just for pizza. Then more orders took me here to pick up. And finally Reddit posts would consistently rate this joint as a top pizza spot in Scarborough. So finally one night I ordered using a delivery app with a code/discount/deal whatever and once eating...that’s when it was confirmed...It’s fantastic! I have ordered once a week since. With the exception of once, I have ordered the double cheese, double pepperoni (light on the sauce thick crust upgrade) every time. The one time I strayed and added mushrooms and sausage I wasn’t as impressed. So sticking with what I know is super tasty! Pictured here is a medium that came to 24 including all fees, tips and 30% discount from Doordash. A bit late after diving in to take the pic, but it may actually give a more true perspective on the pizza including cross section etc. This particular night was the first time I had an issue with the order as the purchased creamy garlic dip was not included in the box but things happen, it was likely a busy Friday night and was missed. Doordash offered a 5 refund/credit immediately. Still a 5 as far as I’m concerned.

Great-tasting pizzas. Ordered the Philly steak and the steak slices are thinly-sliced but adequately seasoned. The Margherita is also amazing, filled with sweet, juicy tomatoes. The Tandoori pizza is another winner but can be a bit too salty. And customer service is excellent, Baker will explain the ingredients and how your pizza is made. Pizza on Fire is worth a visit- go and give it a try.

Tried Pizza on Fire and was really impressed! They offer halal options, which is great. We got extra cheese and pepperoni for the kids, and it was delicious—the cheese, pepperoni, and crust all tasted top quality. You can tell they use good ingredients. They also had a wide variety of other pizzas I’d love to try next time. Definitely worth a visit, and I’d come back if I’m in the area again!

100% making this a regular weekend takeout spot. Pizza was fantastic. I was intrigued by the combination of tandoori chicken and avocados, and while it might seem like a far stretch, I think this spot does a great job at balancing the fattiness of the avocados and the punch from the tandoori flavored chicken. As many others have claimed, they do not mess with your toppings - there's a ton for you to feel full after 2 slices! The cook on the entire pizza was perfection. We also ordered an oven baked pasta, which ended up being a bonus through Uber Eats. This was a great addition, but the takeaway was definitely the pizza.

Honestly this place is a gem to have up in Scarborough. It really is one of the top places to grab a pie in the city. The ingredients were quality and the pizza itself was full of flavor. Really happy to pizza this good without going downtown.

Pizza tasted so good! Never had such good pizza in Toronto. Lots of cheese and pizza is very flavourful and not dry at all. Love the Philly steak and chicken tandoori pizza, chicken wings with hot sauce is also super tasty!